An Unexpected Guest

There's a bustle of leaves
 As we move out of sight
 13 is our number
 And the moon shines red tonight
 We gather to learn
 The whispers from afar
 Knowledge and witchcraft
 Curses and spells from a portal left ajar
 A midnight meeting
 Down by the ruined church
 Oh, spirits and demons, from stranger eons
 Who will be the presence here tonight?
 You... have chosen to join this mass
 Only you know why you're here and why you chose tonight
 Leave all worldly faith
 And it will come to pass
 Don't break the circle
 Don't break the chant
 And oooh,
 Avoid its eyes!
 A midnight meeting
 Down by the ruined church
 Oh, spirits and demons, from stranger eons
 Who will be the presence here tonight?
 But wait, what is this presence here?
 It's so much stronger than before!
 Oh no, why is this presence here?
 This is not who we chanted for!
 This is not who we chanted for!
 It's so much stronger than before!
 The circle is brought to its knees,
 Oh why did we catch his eye!
 The circle is under his will,
 And our coven catches fire...
 A midnight meeting
 Down by the ruined church
 Out of all the spirits and demons
 We should have known
 Who will be the presence here tonight?
 Out of all the spirits and demons,
 We should have known
 The unexpected presence would come to claim his own!