The First Time (Natalie's Song)

Calm down, pull yourself together, it'll be alright
 Regrets, you're so completely useless
 But I can't go back
 But if she wanted me to stay, how could I go?
 I should have known it was the first time
 You can't be giving back what you take, it's all on me
 I can't believe it was the first time
 I wonder, how she will remember me as time goes by
 Was it just how she was imagining?
 If I called tonight would she tell me why?
 But if she wanted me to stay, how could I go?
 You can't be giving back what you take, it's all on me
 I can't believe it was the first time
 Did it mean everything?
 'Cause I can feel her tears fall to the ground
 Would it be like the first time, oh?
 But if she wanted me to stay
 You can't be giving back what you take, it's all on me
 I can't believe it was the first time
 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah
 I can't believe it was her first time